Build your box

Pick your 3 sleeves

Each sleeve holds 4 bagels of one flavor. Choose up to 3 flavors (12 bagels total).

Build your box

Add-ons & Plan

Customize your order with tasty add-ons and choose how often you'd like fresh bagels delivered.

0 of 3 sleeves selected

Each sleeve holds 4 bagels of one flavor. Choose up to 3 flavors for your box (12 bagels total).

Our bagels

Choose your flavors

Hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked the New York way.

  • Plain

    Plain

    0
  • Everything

    Everything

    0
  • Sesame

    Sesame

    0
  • Poppy

    Poppy

    0
  • Onion

    Onion

    0
  • Garlic

    Garlic

    0
  • Cinnamon Raisin

    Cinnamon Raisin

    0
  • Egg

    Egg

    0
  • Whole Wheat

    Whole Wheat

    0
  • Pumpernickel

    Pumpernickel

    0
  • Authentic NY BagelsBaked the traditional way.
  • Always FreshBaked to order, never frozen.
  • Fast Nationwide ShippingGet fresh bagels at your door.
0 / 3
Free shipping
Total today $45.95

Good to know

How does the box work?

Every dozen is 3 sleeves of 4 bagels. Pick a flavor for each sleeve — up to 3 flavors, or the same flavor in every sleeve.

Where do you ship, and how fast?

We ship from our commissary on Long Island, NY, and only ship Monday through Wednesday. If you place an order Wednesday through Sunday, it ships fresh the following Monday. We ship to the lower 48 states and Washington, DC — we can't ship to Alaska, Hawaii, US territories, APO/FPO addresses or outside the US.

How should I store my bagels?

We don't use preservatives. Once your bagels are delivered, eat them within 24 hours and freeze what you don't eat. When you're ready, microwave for 30 seconds, toast and enjoy.